──LIVE · AIRED · NOVEMBER 20, 2026

GTA 6 and game of the year: why bigger budgets are the wrong lesson

GTA 6 may take game of the year, but Colan argued on Never Entertained that unlimited budgets are the wrong lesson. The panel's better example was Capcom.

──── RECAP + NOTES

GTA 6 landed with a 99 on Metacritic, as Greg read it on air, tying the original Ocarina of Time. The Never Entertained panel spent the show arguing over whether that makes it game of the year while viewers voted live. The more useful argument for anyone who makes games was a different one: what the industry will take from it, and whether that is the right thing to take.

Is a 99 proof that money makes masterpieces?

Colan made the strongest case for GTA 6 and, in the same breath, warned against the obvious takeaway. In his telling, Rockstar has been building on itself since the late nineties and earned the right to spend this kind of money because of the steady income from GTA Online. It is the result of a track record, not a template another studio can buy into.

“You cannot give game developers unlimited money, and they will not always come out the other side with this kind of game.”

— Colan, Never Entertained

Colan said most developers will never come close to a game like this, so treating unlimited budgets as the lesson does not hold up for most studios.

Is Capcom the turnaround worth studying?

Colan made the case that Capcom is the clearest lesson of the year. He said it reinvented its business in the late 2010s around remakes, new IP and sequels, and that it is not afraid to release monster hits like Monster Hunter and Resident Evil in the first quarter, after Christmas.

Stephen agreed and added that people overlook Capcom's transition from console to PC in 2020, pointing to the company's public data. Simon's version was consistency, with continuity of teams and iteration. The common thread is a studio that picks its moments rather than one trying to outspend everyone.

Does the Mandy mission count as playing?

Simon went after the GTA 6 moment Colan had mentioned, the second mission with a character named Mandy. Simon said you cannot choose what you say to her or do anything beyond what the scene tells you, and called it "quite an interactive movie." He set it against his own pick, Phantom Blade Zero, which he called pure video game. It is a useful reminder that a prestige score and a player's sense of agency are not the same measurement.

Who do awards actually help?

The panel's read was that awards help some games and not others. Colan said he had been sent a couple of graphs, one showing the impact of the nomination on Clair Obscur's sales. No figure was given on air.

Colan said a nomination is not going to move Resident Evil sales, and Amir added that it will not move any PlayStation title either. Simon went further, saying that even if GTA 6 does not win, it will not change the game's commercial success. Greg's view was that smaller indie darlings benefit most from the exposure.

Why do Western awards miss China's biggest game?

Amir offered a simple test. Drawing on several years working for a Chinese company, he said that if you ask what the best game to come out of China is, the answer is Honor of Kings, which many people in the West do not know. He said the emphasis there is still on mobile and forever games, and argued that a forever game cannot win the top prize at The Game Awards because of a narrow idea of prestige games. Anyone reading the industry through its awards is reading only part of it.

Is the verdict on GTA 6 in yet?

Not according to Simon, who argued that GTA 6's real test is how it is reconsidered and how it endures once players are into the sandbox, open world, GTA Online and PC mods. He also noted that the four months between The Game Awards in December and the BAFTAs in April leave room for that reconsideration. A 99 at launch is a starting point for the conversation, not the end of it.

Keep the conversation going

The full show has every case in the bracket, the live vote and the arguments the panel did not settle.

Watch the full Never Entertained replay

Join the Player Driven Discord

──── THE OPERATOR'S BRIEFING

Get the Tuesday briefing.

Three things every Tuesday: the week's best essay, the next live drop, and one thing we're still arguing about internally.

No spam. Unsubscribe with one click.

Ready for more? Join the Discord community or see the Academy.

──── WANT THE RECEIPTS?

Open the latest Intel drop.

Source-toggle Newzoo's top-20 charts, see the all-four club, run the money-versus-attention map. Player Driven Intel is the data side of the show.

OPEN THE INTEL DROP
EPISODE WINDOW · November 2026